Who Is Liable for a Truck Accident?

April 19, 2024 | Thomas L. Stroble
Who Is Liable for a Truck Accident?

Commercial truck accidents frequently happen when trucking companies, truck drivers, and others commit negligent acts. If you suffered injuries in a truck accident that a negligent individual or entity caused, you may recover monetary damages.

A knowledgeable Michigan truck accident attorney in your area can meet with you to discuss your case and determine the compensation you may be eligible to receive. Additionally, your lawyer can file a claim with the appropriate insurance company, negotiate on your behalf, or litigate your case to a resolution in court.

Schedule a Free Initial Consultation Today!

Potentially Responsible Parties in a Commercial Truck Accident Case

In commercial truck accidents, determining potentially responsible parties can be complex. These accidents involve multiple factors and individuals, making it crucial to identify fault.

First, the commercial truck driver is often a primary party under scrutiny. They are responsible for operating their vehicle safely, following all applicable traffic laws, and obeying all state and federal motor carrier regulations.

If the truck driver was negligent, such as by driving under the influence, speeding, or driving while fatigued, they can be held liable for the resulting accident.

Secondly, the trucking company employing the driver may share some responsibility for the accident. Trucking companies have a duty to ensure that their drivers are properly trained, adhere to motor carrier regulations, and maintain their vehicles.

If the company neglects these responsibilities, such as by pushing drivers to meet unrealistic schedules or failing to maintain their fleet, they can be held accountable.

Thirdly, manufacturers of truck parts or components may be implicated. If a defective part contributed to the accident, such as faulty brakes or tires, the manufacturer can be liable for the resulting damages.

Furthermore, shippers or cargo loaders sometimes play a role in commercial truck accidents. Improperly loaded cargo can affect the truck’s balance, center of gravity, and overall stability, increasing the risk of truck accidents.

Moreover, the parties responsible for negligently loading cargo can share some liability for the resulting damages.

You can hold maintenance providers or third-party contractors involved in servicing the truck accountable. If inadequate maintenance contributed to the accident, such as failure to inspect or repair essential components, you can hold the maintenance provider responsible.

Additionally, governmental entities can be implicated in certain cases. Poor road conditions, inadequate signage, or faulty traffic signals may contribute to certain truck accidents. If governmental agencies fail to maintain safe roadways or address known hazards, can hold them liable for the resulting injuries and damages.

An experienced truck accident attorney in your jurisdiction can thoroughly investigate the circumstances surrounding your collision and work to identify all potentially responsible parties.

Types of Physical and Mental Injuries in a Truck Collision

In truck accidents resulting from others’ negligence, both mental and physical injuries can arise, often leaving victims with long-lasting impairments. 

Understanding the most common types of these injuries is essential for recognizing their effects and seeking appropriate medical and legal assistance.

Physical injuries are among the most apparent consequences of truck accidents. These injuries can range from minor cuts and bruises to severe trauma, including broken bones, spinal cord injuries, and traumatic head and brain injuries (TBIs).

Whiplash, a neck injury that frequently results from sudden jerking movements, is also common in truck accidents due to the force of impact. These physical injuries can lead to significant pain, disability, and long-term medical treatment.

In addition to physical injuries, truck accidents can cause various mental and emotional injuries.

Post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) is prevalent among accident survivors, causing various symptoms, such as flashbacks, nightmares, and anxiety.

Depression and anxiety disorders are also common, as some victims may struggle to cope with the aftermath of their accident, including physical pain, financial strain, and abrupt changes in their lifestyle.

These mental injuries can have a profound effect on a victim’s overall quality of life and may require ongoing therapy and support.

Furthermore, truck accidents can result in emotional distress and psychological trauma for victims and their families. Experiencing a traumatic event like a truck crash can lead to feelings of extreme helplessness, grief, and fear.

Family members may experience guilt, anger, or depression as they navigate the aftermath of the accident and support their loved ones in recovery. These emotional injuries can be just as debilitating as physical injuries and may require professional counseling or therapy to address.

Moreover, the financial consequences of truck accidents can exacerbate mental and emotional distress. Property damage, lost income, and medical expenses can create significant financial burdens for victims and their families.

The stress of dealing with insurance claims, financial uncertainty, and legal proceedings can further contribute to mental health complications, including depression and anxiety.

If you suffered injuries in a recent truck accident, your top priority should be getting the medical treatment that you need to recover. Additionally, you need to consult with a truck accident attorney right away about your potential legal options.

Elements of a Truck Accident Claim or Lawsuit

In a commercial truck accident claim or lawsuit, several legal elements must be satisfied to prove liability and recover compensation for injuries and other losses. Additionally, specific types of evidence are necessary to meet the legal burden of proof and support the victim’s case.

First, to establish liability successfully, the injured truck accident victim (or plaintiff) must establish that the truck driver, trucking company, or other potentially responsible party (or defendant) owed a legal duty of reasonable care to others on the road.

This duty requires them to operate their vehicle safely, follow traffic laws and regulations, and abide by all motor carrier regulations.

Secondly, the plaintiff must show that the defendant breached this duty of care through negligent actions or omissions. For example, if the truck driver was speeding, engaging in distracted driving, or driving while intoxicated, they may be considered negligent.

Thirdly, the plaintiff must prove that the defendant’s negligence directly caused the accident, as well as the resulting injuries and damages. This causation element requires establishing a clear nexus between the defendant’s acts or omissions and the injuries or other harm that the victim suffered.

To satisfy the legal burden of proof and support these elements, various types of evidence are necessary. One crucial type of evidence is accident-scene evidence, including videos, photos, and witness statements. These can help reconstruct the events leading up to the accident and establish how it occurred.

Additionally, medical evidence is essential to document the extent of the victim’s injuries – and the effects of those injuries on the victim’s life. Medical records, doctor reports, and expert testimony can provide valuable insight into the severity of the victim’s injuries, along with the victim’s long-term prognosis.

Moreover, evidence related to the defendant’s conduct and compliance (or lack thereof) with regulations is crucial. This may include driver logs, maintenance records, and inspection reports to demonstrate whether the defendant followed all of the applicable legal requirements and industry standards.

Furthermore, electronic evidence, such as black box data from the truck’s onboard recording devices, can provide important information about the vehicle’s braking, speed, and other critical factors just before the accident occurred.

Eyewitness testimony can corroborate the victim’s account of the accident and establish fault on the part of the truck driver or trucking company.

Negotiating with the Insurance Company for Favorable Settlement Compensation

Following a commercial truck accident, a truck accident lawyer plays a crucial role in negotiating with the insurance company to seek fair compensation for the victim’s injuries and losses. 

  • First, the lawyer assesses the truck accident case by gathering evidence, reviewing medical records and bills, and analyzing the overall circumstances of the accident. A thorough understanding of the entire case allows them to determine the true extent of the victim’s damages and the liability of the at-fault individual or entity. 
  • Next, the lawyer communicates with the insurance company on behalf of the accident victim. They may send a demand letter outlining the victim’s injuries, medical expenses, lost income, and other damages incurred as a result of the accident. This letter serves as a starting point for settlement negotiations in the case.
  • During negotiations, the lawyer advocates for the victim’s interests by presenting evidence of the at-fault party’s liability and the extent of the victim’s losses and damages. They may use medical reports, medical bills, witness statements, accident reconstruction analyses, and other evidence to support their arguments.
  • The lawyer can also counter any arguments or attempts by the insurance company to shift blame onto the victim or downplay the seriousness of the accident or injuries. An experienced truck accident lawyer will strive to demonstrate the full effect of the accident on the victim’s life and the need for adequate compensation to cover medical bills, pain and suffering, lost earnings, and other potential losses. 
  • Throughout the negotiation process, the lawyer remains diligent in pursuing the best possible result for the truck accident victim. They may engage in ongoing discussions with the insurance company adjuster handling the claim, making strategic offers and counteroffers at the appropriate times to reach a fair settlement.
  • If the truck accident case is not resolved via settlement, the lawyer may advise the victim on their options for pursuing legal action through a lawsuit (i.e., litigation). In this instance, the lawyer continues to advocate for the victim’s rights in court, presenting evidence and arguments to secure a favorable verdict or settlement.

Overall, a truck accident lawyer’s negotiation skills and legal experience are invaluable in dealing with the complexities of insurance company negotiations following an accident.

By effectively representing the victim’s interests and advocating for fair compensation, they ensure that victims receive the financial support necessary to make a full recovery and obtain the justice they deserve.

Types of Damages Following a Truck Collision

Following a commercial truck accident, victims may be entitled to various damages to compensate for their losses and injuries. These damages provide financial support for both their economic and non-economic hardships.

First, victims may seek compensation for the medical expenses they incurred due to injuries sustained in the accident. This includes costs for hospitalization, doctor visits, surgeries and other procedures, prescription medications, physical or occupational therapy, and ongoing medical treatment necessary for recovery.

Secondly, victims can pursue compensation for lost income if their injuries prevent them from working. This includes income that the victim lost from having to attend medical appointments, along with any future earning capacity that the injuries diminished.

Thirdly, compensation may be available to the accident victim for property damage, such as repairs or replacement of vehicles damaged in the accident. This can include not only the cost of replacing or repairing the victim’s vehicle but also any personal belongings within the vehicle that sustained damage in the accident.

Furthermore, victims may seek compensation for non-economic damages, which are more intangible losses that affect one’s overall quality of life. This includes pain and suffering endured as a result of the accident, as well as emotional distress, mental anguish, and loss of enjoyment of life.

Additionally, victims may be entitled to receive compensation for loss of earning capacity if their injuries prevent them from pursuing their usual occupation or earning potential. This considers the long-term effect of the victim’s injuries on their ability to earn money.

Moreover, punitive damages may be available in truck accident cases where the at-fault party’s actions were grossly negligent, egregious, or reckless. The ultimate goal of these damages is to punish the defendant for their wrongful conduct and prevent similar incidents from occurring in the future.

Overall, victims of commercial truck accidents may be entitled to recover damages to compensate for their physical and mental injuries. This includes compensation for medical expenses, lost income, property damage, pain and suffering, loss of earning capacity, and punitive damages in certain cases.

A skilled truck accident attorney can help victims maximize their total monetary award through a favorable settlement offer from the insurance company or litigation result in court.

Thomas L. Stroble , Michigan Truck Accident Lawyer
Thomas Stroble, Michigan Truck Accident Attorney

Contact a Truck Accident Lawyer Right Away

Individuals who suffer injuries in a truck accident may remain incapacitated for a long period of time. In addition to seeking the medical treatment you need for your injuries, you should retain a knowledgeable truck accident lawyer in your area as soon as possible.

Your attorney can aggressively advocate for your legal interests throughout the process and work to recover the full damages you need to become whole again.

Thomas L. Stroble Author Image

Thomas L. Stroble


Mr. Stroble is a highly accomplished graduate of Michigan State University, with degrees in both science and law. He specializes in commercial lawsuits and personal injury cases. Licensed to practice law in Michigan and even the U.S. Supreme Court, he’s a well-qualified legal expert. Besides his career in law, he loves outdoor activities and volunteers as a part-time police officer in Birmingham.

Author's Bio

You Might Be Also Interested In